The Kansas and Wyoming bills target agricultural equipment, while the other bills apply more broadly to the repair of any equipment with embedded electronics. Fortunately, widespread outrage thanks to a YouTube video , of all things pressured Apple into starting a battery replacement program. According to Daniel Mastin, general manager of Videogamesnewyork, an independent video game retailer and repair shop in New York City, if a customer brings in a controller with a broken thumbstick, his or her only recourse is to buy a new controller. The proposed Right to Repair laws known as the Fair Repair Act in some states are designed to make it easier for people to repair their broken electronic equipment—like cell phones, computers, appliances, cameras, and even tractors. The law will have to be agreed by EU member states and the European parliament.
Phone repair law -
The legislation would require manufacturers to release repair information to the public and sell spare parts to owners and independent repair shops. If passed, the laws would give consumers more options than just the manufacturer for repair.
The Kansas and Wyoming bills target agricultural equipment, while the other bills apply more broadly to the repair of any equipment with embedded electronics. Nebraska scheduled a committee hearing for a Right to Repair bill—a necessary step towards it becoming a law.
John Deere—the agricultural machinery giant—has also come out swinging against the bills. No surprise there; John Deere also opposed efforts in to loosen copyright law restrictions that make it more difficult for farmers to fix their high-tech tractors. God forbid! Customers repairing things they paid for and allegedly own? Assist in its development. No word yet whether Apple plans to oppose Right to Repair bills in more states than Nebraska. But we expect it. The bill, SB , died quietly in committee before it could go to a vote.
But the New York bill has been reintroduced for the legislative session as S We respect your privacy. All email addresses you provide will be used just for sending this story. The push for right-to-repair laws in electronics is heating up in state legislatures across the country.
Basically, these laws address what happens when an electronic product such as a phone or gaming console breaks. Can you fix it yourself or get it fixed wherever you want? Often the answer to both questions is no, and your only real choice is to go back to the manufacturer for repairs. Update: On April 10, the Federal Trade Commission warned six unnamed companies that sell automobiles, video game consoles, and cellular devices about the language they use to dissuade consumers from attempting to repair their own devices.
The FTC noted that unless companies make repair parts available or have received a waiver from the FTC they are generally prohibited from using language that suggests consumers will void their warranty if they remove a warranty sticker or use third-party repair parts.
In California, state Assembly Member Susan Talamantes Eggman, D-Stockton, recently introduced a bill requiring electronics makers to sell replacement parts and provide access to diagnostic tools and device schematics to consumers and independent repair shops.
California is the 18th state to propose such legislation. The freedom to repair your own electronics is laid out in the Digital Standard , a CR-led project to help set expectations for how manufacturers should handle privacy, security, and other digital rights. Until , carmakers routinely kept vital diagnostic and repair tools out of the hands of neighborhood mechanics , despite loud protests and attempts at state and federal legislation to make the practice illegal.
According to Daniel Mastin, general manager of Videogamesnewyork, an independent video game retailer and repair shop in New York City, if a customer brings in a controller with a broken thumbstick, his or her only recourse is to buy a new controller. The ESA did not provide a comment in time for publication.
For instance, many shops—and consumers—can replace computer hard drives. If you crack your iPhone screen you can go to a repair shop or order the parts and try doing the repair yourself.
In , Apple reversed an unpopular policy under which such work voided iPhone warranties. But Apple is frequently cited by those arguing in favor of right-to-repair laws. Consumers in those states might be able to find an authorized shop capable of making some repairs. Christopher Pearson, D-Chittenden, who introduced right-to-repair legislation earlier this year.
Pearson says that when the camera in his iPhone which he uses to scan documents for his own small business malfunctioned, he was told by a local Best Buy it would take five to seven business days to get fixed. But right to repair can force manufacturers to stop impeding those things from happening. Apple is widely reported to have lobbied against right-to-repair laws in multiple states, even when tractors, not smartphones , were at the crux of the debate.
Apple added that getting repairs at unauthorized centers could result in problems such as a Home button not working properly or excessive battery consumption. The Security Innovation Center, founded in late , is among several groups that argue against right-to-repair laws. CTA did not respond to a request for comment. And they hope for a repeat of what happened in the auto industry.
We depend on our smartphones for many things, but what happens when you drop your device on a hard surface?Our friends at Repair. An earlier upgrade to the eco-design law to set repair efficiency standards for toasters and reair was abandoned over a feared law backlashafter a hostile tabloid phone during the Brexit referendum. Show comments commenting powered by Facebook. By Nicholas Deleon. We depend on our smartphones for many things, but what happens when you drop your device on a hard surface?
No word yet whether Apple plans to oppose Right to Repair bills in more states than Nebraska. But we expect it.
The bill, SB , died quietly in committee before it could go to a vote. But the New York bill has been reintroduced for the legislative session as S Our friends at Repair.
But, we are a bunch of folks who like to fix stuff. And a bunch of folks can make a bunch of noise. Or shoot them an email. And keep those RightToRepair tweets coming. Fix Your Stuff. Related Stories. Add Comment. Add Comment Cancel. Try an Apple Authorized Service Provider. In other words, they want to make it as difficult as possible for anyone but them to fix your broken stuff.
Remember the original iPod? Fortunately, widespread outrage thanks to a YouTube video , of all things pressured Apple into starting a battery replacement program. There was also the Error 53 scandal with the iPhone a couple of years ago. The second explanation is that Right to Repair legislation would require manufacturers to sell genuine replacement parts and tools, as well as make repair documentation available to anyone.
As of right now, 17 states have introduced legislation that would give independent repair shops the same access that the manufacturers have to genuine parts, tools, and information that would help aid in the repair process for consumer electronics. No laws have officially been passed yet in the consumer electronics sector, but the Automotive Right to Repair Law was passed in Massachusetts in , which has a similar template to these new bills.
The good news is that this legislation is gaining steam, especially since the whole iPhone battery scandal was uncovered recently. So would these Right to Repair laws finally allow you to bust open your devices without voiding the warranty? They have to prove that your DIY repair or modification caused something else in the device to malfunction.